Healthy Skepticism Library item: 8771
Warning: This library includes all items relevant to health product marketing that we are aware of regardless of quality. Often we do not agree with all or part of the contents.
Publication type: media release
Vasella questioned at the General Meeting in Basel about Novartis legal action against India
Berne Declaration 2007 Mar 6
http://www.evb.ch/en/p25012115.html
Full text:
Lausanne, Zurich, 06.03.2007 – At Novartis General Meeting today, the Berne Declaration will urge Dr. Vasella, to drop Novartis legal action against India, which threathens access to affordable generic medicines for millions of poor people in developing countries. The Berne Declaration with Oxfam will urge attending shareholders to make the same request to the company. Moreover investors are starting to question Novartis policy on the issue.
Concerns about Novartis legal action in India is being raised by investors too.
Dan Rosan from the US-based Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (ICCR), an association of 275 faith- based institutional investors, states: “Novartis has substantially invested in neglected disease research, policy development, and stakeholder engagement, differentiating itself from the rest of the pharmaceutical industry. Now, their actions in this case are undermining that record … Novartis’ legal tactics in this case have raised the stakes higher than the several thousand Indian patients relying on Glivec, to involve the millions of people kept alive today by generic AIDS drugs from India.”
“Novartis are threatening their own future profits as well as access to medicines – putting at risk their reputation in key emerging markets and undermining public acceptance of the intellectual property regime on which pharmaceutical profits depend.” says Alex van der Velden from FairPensions, the British campaign for responsible investment.
Julien Reinhard from the Berne Declaration will intervene at today Novartis Annual General Meeting, to raise the issue directly to Dr. Vasella. The Berne Declaration with Oxfam will distribute material to attending shareholders urging them to do what is in their power in order that Novartis drops its legal action against India.
Julien Reinhard, Berne Declaration: “The Novartis case in India goes beyond the case of anticancer medicine Glivec® because its directly challenge an internationally recognized public health safeguard. This has far beyond India alone. The concerns expressed all over the world by NGOs, individuals and personalities like former President of the Swiss Confederation Ruth Dreifuss or South African Archbishop Desmond Tutu, deserve to be taken seriously by the company. It is time for Novartis to show corporate responsibility by droping its case in India.”
Celine Charveriat, Oxfam International: “It is difficult to see how a company which prides itself on its philanthropy in the developing world can at the same time be engaged in a lawsuit which would undermine access to affordable medicines. Novartis has apparently not learned the lessons from the 2001 South Africa case, when big Pharma sued the South African government for trying to uphold public health and was forced to back down.”
Contact:
Berne Declaration: Julien Reinhard, +41(0)76 327 67 41 (mobile),
+41(0)21 620 03 06 (office)
Background information:
Following rejection of its patent application for the cancer drug Glivec, Novartis filed suit against the Indian government to fight the patent rejection. At the same time, the company launched a second legal action against a key public health provision in the Indian law (section 3d). A Novartis victory in the Indian case would cut off access to affordable generic versions of many medicines, in India and abroad. India is a key exporter of low-cost, quality medicines to much of the developing world, in particular HIV/AIDS medicines.
In October 2006 the Berne Declaration has sent a letter to Novartis requesting to drop its legal action. This letter is endorsed today by more than 70 NGOs from Switzerland and the rest of the world as well as by several personalites like Ruth Dreifuss, former President of the Swiss Confederation and Jean Ziegler, United Nations Special Rapporteur on the right to food.
More informations on:
www.evb.ch/en/f25000047.html
