Healthy Skepticism Library item: 3831
Warning: This library includes all items relevant to health product marketing that we are aware of regardless of quality. Often we do not agree with all or part of the contents.
Publication type: news
Prescription Drugs: Nine States Looking Into Pharmaceutical Company Gifts to Physicians
kaisernetwork.org ( The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation) 2006 Feb 17
http://www.kaisernetwork.org/daily_reports/rep_index.cfm?DR_ID=35488
Notes:
Ralph Faggotter’s Comments:
A first step towards reducing drug company gifts to doctors is having some transparency in the process.
Full text:
Daily Health Policy Report
Prescription Drugs | Nine States Looking Into Pharmaceutical Company Gifts to Physicians
[Feb 17, 2006]
At least nine states are considering bills that would require pharmaceutical companies to publicly report annual gifts to physicians, hospitals and pharmacists, the
USA Today reports. Maine, Minnesota, Vermont, West Virginia and the District of Columbia currently have laws requiring the reporting of gifts. California requires that drug companies declare they are in compliance with federal and industry gift guidelines. Many of the state proposals under consideration this year are modeled after the Vermont law, enacted in 2002, which requires drugmakers to report to the state’s attorney general all gifts of $25 or more given to doctors, hospitals or pharmacists. Aggregate numbers are published but not the names of gift recipients. Some of the state proposals would be more restrictive, such as a Massachusetts bill that would ban all gifts to medical professionals from drugmakers. Massachusetts state Sen. Mark Montigny (D), sponsor of the bill, said, “If a doctor needs a Caribbean vacation or a mug or a pen, he or she is probably not very successful and needs to be in another business.” Montigny added, “The No. 1 thing that keeps government and corporate officials honest is transparency.” Ron Buzzeo, chief regulatory officer for Dendrite International — which advises the pharmaceutical industry — said, “Within a year or two, we may have 20 or 25 states with these restrictions.” The Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America says such laws are unnecessary. Marjorie Powell, senior assistant general counsel for PhRMA, said, “All of this is very heavily regulated by the
FDA, which controls what companies can say to physicians about their drugs. We don’t think there is a particular need for states to get involved.” Powell and others said that the industry has cut back on large gifts and that visits from sales representatives who bring free lunches to doctors provide an “important educational function,” the
USA Today reports (Appleby,
USA Today, 2/17).
Gifts Debate Examined
In related news, the Detroit Free Press on Friday examined the debate over whether “the practice of doctors accepting freebies … undermines patient care and should be banned.” A recent article in the Journal of the American Medical Association found that about 90% of the pharmaceutical industry’s marketing budget is directed at doctors. The JAMA article proposed that academic medical centers end the practice of accepting gifts. Pfizer CEO Hank McKinnell on Monday said the JAMA proposal was unnecessary because of a voluntary code of conduct adopted by the drug industry three years ago (Merx, Detroit Free Press, 2/17).
