Healthy Skepticism Library item: 1617

Warning: This library includes all items relevant to health product marketing that we are aware of regardless of quality. Often we do not agree with all or part of the contents.

Publication type: Journal Article

Kligman M, Culver CM.
An analysis of interpersonal manipulation.
J Med Philos 1992 Apr; 17:(2):173-97

Abstract:

The term ‘manipulation’ is frequently employed but rarely discussed or defined in psychiatric circles. This paper reviews previous conceptual analyses of the term by philosophers and psychiatrists, and examines its use in ordinary discourse. A series of characteristics which comprise the conceptual core of the term when it is unambiguously applied in interpersonal settings are proposed. Manipulation is contrasted with other behavior control methods such as rational persuasion and coercion, with emphasis on the role played by deception and the communicative context in which the manipulative transaction occurs. It is argued that manipulative behavior is fundamentally intentional, and the usefulness of the concept of ‘unconscious manipulation’ is questioned. Though the proposal that Manipulative Personality Disorder be formally recognized as a new diagnostic category is rejected, it is urged that the concept of manipulation receive wider attention and discussion within the mental health community.

Keywords:
Attitude of Health Personnel Defense Mechanisms* Humans Interpersonal Relations* Motivation Personality Disorders/classification Personality Disorders/diagnosis* Personality Disorders/psychology Persuasive Communication* Philosophy, Medical* Power (Psychology) Unconscious (Psychology)